Zestfor

Leadership & Management

Leading from the Front vs Leading from Behind: Which Leadership Style Works Best?

Leader guiding a team in discussion, representing leading from the front

Throughout business history, one principle remains steadfast: failing teams, departments, and organisations rediscover success through leadership, not mere management. Leading from the front has become increasingly vital in today’s complex business environment, yet many leaders struggle to implement this approach effectively.

Recent research indicates that 70% of leaders need to develop a broader range of leadership behaviours to meet current and future business demands. This shift reflects changing workforce expectations and the increasingly complex challenges facing UK organisations.


What Does Leading from the Front Mean?

Leading from the front means demonstrating leadership by taking an active, visible role in what you’re directing others to do. This leadership style involves going first, showing how tasks should be accomplished, and setting standards through personal example.

As a leadership style, leading from the front means playing an active and visible role in the everyday running of a company or organisation. Business leaders who adopt this style choose to connect with team members, customers, and stakeholders on the “front line” of the operation.

Many leaders hold the belief that they cannot ask their team to do something they wouldn’t do themselves. Whilst this principle has merit, it can sometimes prove unrealistic in practice. The challenge lies in understanding when to lead from the front and when alternative strategies might yield better results.

Key Characteristics of Leading from the Front

Leading from the front encompasses several critical elements:

  • Visible participation in day-to-day operations and challenging tasks
  • Personal demonstration of expected behaviours and work standards
  • Active involvement in problem-solving and decision-making processes
  • Direct communication with team members at all levels
  • Accountability for both team successes and failures

When to Lead from the Front: Practical Applications

Crisis Management and Change Implementation

Leading from the front becomes essential during:

  • Organisational crises requiring immediate, decisive action
  • Major strategic changes that need visible leadership commitment
  • New process implementation where teams need clear guidance
  • Challenging market conditions requiring hands-on leadership

Leading from the front can give you the chance to be more responsive to crises or difficult situations. Since those who lead from the front often have access to on-the-ground information, they can react quickly and directly as a situation changes.

Building Team Morale and Engagement

Leading from the front allows you to interact directly with employees, whether they’re in leadership roles or lower-level positions. This strategy can boost morale and create greater organisational cohesion.

Leading from the front creates several advantages:

  • Enhanced team confidence through visible leadership presence
  • Improved communication between management and front-line staff
  • Faster problem resolution through direct involvement
  • Stronger organisational culture through shared experiences

The Alternative Alternative: Leading From Behind

Learning from Global Leadership Wisdom

The concept of leading from behind might initially sound peculiar, yet it represents a sophisticated leadership strategy. Linda Hill of Harvard Business School references Nelson Mandela’s autobiography, where he compared effective leadership with shepherding: “He stays behind the flock, letting the most nimble go out ahead, whereupon the others follow, not realising that all along they are being directed from behind.”¹

Leading from behind involves deliberately stepping back after establishing direction and expectations. It’s about trusting and empowering teams to navigate their way to achieving objectives without micromanagement stifling their potential.

The Philosophy of Service Leadership

Simon Sinek’s research highlights organisations where senior leaders prioritise their team’s needs above their own.² This approach embodies the principle that true leadership requires placing others’ development and success at the forefront of decision-making.


Modern Workforce Expectations

The Changing Workplace Dynamic

Today’s workforce brings different expectations to the workplace. Modern employees increasingly judge organisations not merely on financial performance or product quality, but on relationships with workers, customers, and communities.³

Current workplace statistics reveal significant leadership challenges:

  • Only 29% of employees perceive their leader as demonstrating authentic leadership
  • 76% of employees report that work-related stress has negatively affected their personal relationships
  • A substantial number of leaders lack confidence in their own management structure

Addressing Modern Leadership Challenges

Leading from the front addresses these contemporary challenges by:

  • Building management confidence through hands-on experience and team feedback
  • Demonstrating authenticity through visible, consistent actions
  • Reducing workplace stress by providing clear direction and support

The Rise of Adaptive Leadership

Navigating Uncertainty in Modern Business

Adaptive leadership has emerged as the ability to anticipate organisational needs and lead effectively during uncertain times. This approach has become increasingly vital as businesses navigate regulatory changes, technological advancement, and evolving market conditions.

Core Elements of Adaptive Leadership

Modern leaders must develop three fundamental competencies:

Strategic Anticipation

Leaders require a thorough understanding of market trends, industry conditions, and available strategic options. This involves scenario planning and developing foresight capabilities.

Transparent Accountability

Open decision-making processes and willingness to accept constructive feedback form the foundation of trustworthy leadership.

Organisational Adaptability

Traditional command-and-control models are becoming less effective in today’s dynamic business environment. Leaders must embrace flexibility and continuous learning.⁴


Balancing Leadership Approaches for Maximum Impact

The Risks of Inflexible Leadership Styles

If leaders believe they must always take the lead and make initial mistakes, they risk creating dependency rather than empowerment. This approach can prevent team members from developing independence, taking initiative, and learning through their own experiences.

Encouraging Innovation Through Strategic Leadership

For organisations to thrive, they must innovate and harness their employees’ creativity. The most effective leaders demonstrate flexibility, switching between leading from the front during crises and stepping back to allow teams to flourish during stable periods.

This adaptability in leadership style often determines long-term organisational success. In times of crisis, businesses require leaders to navigate challenging circumstances. However, once stability returns and new directions are established, stepping back allows teams and individuals to develop and excel.


Building Trust Through Leading from the Front

Foundations of Leadership Trust

Trust has become fundamental to leadership effectiveness in contemporary British business. Leaders can build trust through:

  • Explaining the rationale behind decisions – Understanding the “why” helps employees become advocates for change
  • Maintaining transparent communication – Open dialogue about both successes and challenges
  • Demonstrating emotional intelligence – Understanding and managing emotions effectively in professional relationships

Trust-Building Through Leading from the Front

Leading from the front builds trust by:

  • Showing leaders are willing to face the same challenges as their teams
  • Demonstrating commitment through actions, not just words
  • Creating opportunities for direct feedback and communication
  • Establishing credibility through hands-on problem-solving

The Future of Leadership

Navigating Complexity

Leaders today operate in an increasingly complex environment characterised by volatility, uncertainty, and rapid change. Digital transformation, regulatory changes, and shifting consumer expectations require leaders to develop new strategies and approaches.

Embracing Digital Transformation

Technology continues to revolutionise industries, requiring leaders to navigate artificial intelligence, digital processes, and data-driven decision-making whilst maintaining human connection and organisational culture5.

Leading from the front in the digital age means:

  • Actively learning and implementing new technologies
  • Maintaining personal connections despite digital transformation
  • Balancing automation with human-centred leadership
  • Demonstrating digital literacy whilst preserving organisational values

Frequently Asked Questions About Leading from the Front

Leading from the front involves taking a visible, active role and personally demonstrating tasks, whilst leading from behind means establishing direction and then empowering teams to achieve objectives independently. Effective leaders understand when each approach is most appropriate.

Consider your team’s capability and the situation. Lead from the front during crises, major changes, or when establishing new processes. Switch to leading from behind when your team demonstrates competence, motivation, and the environment allows for experimentation and growth. The key is reading your team’s needs and adapting accordingly.

Absolutely. Leading from the front in remote environments means being actively present in virtual meetings, regularly checking in with team members, participating in collaborative projects, and maintaining visibility through consistent communication. It involves demonstrating the same work standards and commitment you expect from your team, just through digital channels.


Moving Forward with Purpose

Leading from the front or behind isn’t a binary choice — it’s about developing the judgement to know which approach best serves your team and organisation in any given situation. In our evolving business landscape, successful leaders will be those who master both approaches and understand when to deploy each strategy effectively.

The future belongs to adaptive leaders who can navigate uncertainty, build genuine trust, and empower their teams to achieve exceptional results. The question isn’t which style to choose, but rather how to develop the wisdom to use both appropriately.

References
  1. Hill, L. Leading from Behind. Harvard Business Review.
    https://hbr.org
  2. Sinek, S. Leaders Eat Last.
    https://www.amazon.co.uk/Leaders-Eat-Last-Together-Others/dp/0670923176
  3. Deloitte. (2018). Human Capital Trends Report.
    https://www2.deloitte.com/global/en/pages/human-capital/articles/introduction-human-capital-trends.html
  4. Strategic Leader Coaching. (2024). Adaptive Leadership Strategies.
    https://strategicleadercoaching.ca/2024/02/20/adaptive-leadership-strategy/
  5. IntechOpen. Adaptive Leadership in Digital Transformation.
    https://www.intechopen.com/online-first/1204010

Find the Right Training Programme for You

Zestfor’s training programmes are designed to create lasting change. Whether you’re looking to enhance leadership skills, improve team performance or invest in individual growth, we have a programme that fits. Explore our full range of training opportunities and take the next step in your professional development today.

Website by INDIGO CUBE
Zestfor Logo
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.